Renouncing a French Inheritance: What You Need to Know

Matthew Cameron explains why someone might want to renounce an inheritance from a French estate

Inheriting assets from a French estate might initially seem like a windfall, but the reality can be far more complex. For British nationals and other foreign beneficiaries, accepting a French inheritance comes with significant legal, financial and practical considerations that may outweigh the benefits. Understanding when and why to renounce an inheritance is crucial for making an informed decision.

TAX LIABILITIES

France’s inheritance tax system is one of the most significant factors influencing the decision to renounce. The tax rates are progressive and depend heavily on the relationship between the deceased and the beneficiary. Direct descendants (children and grandchildren) benefit from relatively favourable rates starting at 5% and reaching 45% on amounts exceeding €1.8m, with an allowance of €100,000 per child. However, for more distant relatives, the situation becomes considerably less attractive. Siblings face rates between 35% and 45% with only a €15,932 tax-free allowance. Nieces and nephews are taxed at 55%. The tax rate for unrelated beneficiaries is 60% with a tax-free allowance of €1,594. For British nationals who may have been close friends or distant relatives of the deceased, these rates can make an inheritance financially unviable. When combined with UK tax considerations and reporting requirements, the administrative burden becomes even more substantial.

DEBTS AND LOANS

One of the most critical reasons to consider renunciation is the principle that accepting an inheritance means accepting it in its entirety – both assets and liabilities. French law does not allow beneficiaries to cherry-pick favourable assets while declining debts. If the deceased had outstanding mortgages, personal loans, business debts, unpaid taxes or other financial obligations, these become the responsibility of the heirs. Without thorough due diligence, you might discover that the estate is insolvent or that debts substantially exceed the value of assets. Properties that appear valuable might be encumbered with mortgages or legal claims. The deceased may have provided guarantees for business loans or had tax disputes with French authorities. We have also seen a number of cases where the deceased died in France, following an illness that resulted in care or hospital fees. Such fees can themselves become a debt against the estate. In one case where beneficiaries sought our advice, the hospital fees alone outweighed the value of the house. The beneficiaries had little practical choice than to renounce, allowing the hospital to sell the property to recoup its expenditure. Conducting a comprehensive assessment of the estate’s financial position is essential before accepting, and if this reveals significant liabilities, renunciation might prove to be the prudent choice.

EMOTIONAL TOLL

The French succession process is notoriously bureaucratic and must be handled through a notaire (a French public official who manages estate settlements). The process involves extensive documentation, official translations, apostilled certificates, and compliance with both French and potentially UK legal requirements. For non-French speakers, every document requires certified translation, adding to costs and delays. The timeline for settling a French estate typically extends from several months to over a year, sometimes longer if complications arise. During this period, beneficiaries may need to make multiple trips to France, take time of work, and remain in constant communication with French legal professionals. The emotional toll of navigating a foreign legal system while grieving can be substantial. Professional fees for notaires, lawyers, translators, and cross-border tax advisors can easily reach tens of thousands of euros, significantly eroding the inheritance value. French succession law includes forced heirship rules that protect certain family members regardless of the deceased’s wishes. A portion of the estate (the réserve héréditaire) must go to protected heirs, typically children, which can override provisions in a will. This can create situations where you inherit property in co-ownership with family members you may not know well or with whom you have difficult relationships.

RENUNCIATION RULES

Renunciation can be a strategic tool for family wealth planning. When you renounce a French inheritance from a parent, you will be treated as having predeceased that parent. In this way the inheritance due to you would then usually pass to your children. If you would prefer a legacy from a deceased parent to pass directly to your children, this may prove to be a good method of passing assets down through the generations.

“While it may seem counterintuitive to decline an inheritance, it can protect you from fi nancial loss, administrative burden and ongoing obligations that outweigh any benefits”

However, care needs to be taken before deciding to take such a step. Careful planning and professional advice will be required to ensure the outcome aligns with your intentions and does not create unintended consequences. As an example, if your renunciation would lead to minor children inheriting in your place, the result may actually be a different set of complications: minor children do not have legal capacity to accept a succession, so this would have to be given on their behalf, potentially by a court. The court would have to be involved where a subsequent sale was intended while the child is still a minor.

In addition, you may well find that you are not able to renounce only to part of a deceased parent’s estate: if they had assets in the UK and France, it might be the case that renunciation is ‘all or nothing’.

CHARITABLE AIMS

Another example – perhaps a rather surprising one – where renunciation might be the most suitable option is in relation to a legacy to a charity. One unfortunate consequence of the UK’s departure from the EU is that a UK charity will not automatically qualify for an exemption to inheritance tax. The starting point is that the charity is not related to the deceased, so inheritance tax would apply at 60%.

It is possible to qualify for an exemption, but the process is extremely lengthy, and quite onerous. Where the main asset was a house in France, it follows that a charity may be faced with paying the tax and then hoping to reclaim this, whether from the proceeds of sale or from the slight possibility of an exemption being awarded. Faced with those prospects, one can hardly blame the trustees for deciding to forego the legacy.

Renouncing a French inheritance is a significant decision that requires thorough analysis of the estate’s financial position, your personal circumstances and long-term implications. While it may seem counterintuitive to decline an inheritance, doing so can protect you from financial loss, administrative burden and ongoing obligations that outweigh any benefits.

In practice, the majority of estates on which we are instructed to advise are not insolvent, and rarely do they lead to other instances where renunciation might be the most suitable choice. Sometimes, however, beneficiaries will have little option but to avoid taking any interest from a deceased person’s estate.

Nevertheless, it is always going to be prudent for owners of a French property – whether resident or not – to take detailed advice from legal and tax professionals experienced in cross-border French estates before making this irreversible choice. Identifying potential pitfalls in advance should ensure that you will not leave your beneficiaries with difficult choices to make about accepting or renouncing an estate you have left them.

If you envisage leaving your French estate to more distant relatives, or to charities, then the need to take wills and inheritance planning advice is particularly important.

Matthew Cameron heads the French legal services team at Ashtons Legal

Tel: 0330 1914450

ashtonslegal.co.uk

Lead photo credit : Shutterstock